Past Masters of Western Star Lodge #2
- 1848: Saschel Woods
- 1849: Saschel Woods
- 1850: Saschel Woods
- 1851: Dwight Spencer
- 1852: William Robinson
- 1853: Abner E. Calliway
- 1854: John A. Raymond
- 1855: John A. Raymond
- 1856: Whiting G. West
- 1857: Joseph Isaacs
- 1858: John A Raymond
- 1859: C. Danielson
- 1860: C. Danielson
- 1861: C. Danielson
- 1862: C. Danielson
- 1863: Joseph Isaacs
- 1864: Daniel P. Bystle
- 1865: C. Danielson
- 1866: C. Danielson
- 1867: Adolph Dobrowsky
- 1868: Adolph Dobrowsky
- 1869: Fred B. Chandler
- 1870: Fred B. Chandler
- 1871: Louis Wellendorff
- 1872: Louis Wellendorff
- 1873: Louis Wellendorff
- 1874: William E. Hopping
- 1875: William E. Hopping
- 1876: Chauncey C. Bush
- 1877: Chauncey C. Bush
- 1878: Clay W. Taylor, P.G.M.
- 1879: Clay W. Taylor, P.G.M.
- 1880: James D. Blair
- 1881: James D. Blair
- 1882: James D. Blair
- 1883: Mortimer C. Allen
- 1884: Adolph Dobrowsky
- 1885: Adolph Dobrowsky
- 1886: Daniel P. Bystle
- 1887: James D. Blair
- 1888: Daniel P. Bystle
- 1889: Mortimer C. Allen
- 1890: Morris Mahon
- 1891: Morris Mahon
- 1892: Frank P. Satterlee
- 1893: J. L. Richardson
- 1894: J. L. Richardson
- 1895: J. L. Richardson
- 1896: Jewett Scranton
- 1897: J. L. Richardson
- 1898: Jewett Scranton
- 1899: Edward Sweeny
- 1900: Edward Sweeny
- 1901: J. L. Richardson
- 1902: Nelson E. Lamus
- 1903: Grant A. Schroter
- 1904: Jewett Scranton
- 1905: Charles E. Brown
- 1906: Charles E. Brown
- 1907: William A. Speak
- 1908: B. C. Blair
- 1900: B. C. Blair
- 1910: B. C. Blair
- 1911: Alexander Patterson
- 1912: Alexander Patterson
- 1913: Ralph Ingram
- 1914: Richard B. Ross
- 1915: Ralph Ingram
- 1916: August W. Tillman
- 1917: August W. Tillman
- 1918: August W. Tillman
- 1919: Charles E. Brown
- 1920: George E. Ellington
- 1921: George E. Ellington
- 1922: Jesse W. Carter
- 1923: Lester C. Smith
- 1924: Clifford R. Weigel
- 1925: Fred L. Richardson
- 1926: Joseph Jones
- 1927: David Otto Schnittyer
- 1928: John B. McColl
- 1929: John W. Strode
- 1930: Albert V. Fondahn
- 1931: Samuel Gaston Smith
- 1932: Albert V. Fondahn
- 1933: Royal Tyler Sprague
- 1934: William M. Heffelfinger
- 1935: Bernard E. Gilmore
- 1936: Sherman S. Statton
- 1937: Sherman S. Statton
- 1938: Joseph A. Hart
- 1939: William O. Riley
- 1940: William O. Riley
- 1941: Hugh A. Shuffleton, Sr.
- 1942: Juel G. Huseby
- 1943: Andrew E. Browne
- 1944: Harry D. Williams
- 1945: Rufus A. King
- 1946: Ben A. Mason
- 1947: Fred M. Stulpnagle
- 1948: Walter R. Ray
- 1949: Victor H. Dahlgren
- 1950: Gerald L. Moody
- 1951: Walter S. McDonald
- 1952: Charles E. Hall
- 1953: Charles E. Hall
- 1954: J. Forrest Smith
- 1955: Walter L. Ericson
- 1956: Charles E. Leas
- 1957: Troy J. Wolverton
- 1948: William H. Cox
- 1959: Joseph M. Bolton
- 1960: Ray H. Quibell
- 1961: Floyd J. Hyatt
- 1962: Laures H. Fretts
- 1963: James M. James
- 1964: Albert L. Derby
- 1965: Kendal L. Dittus
- 1966: William W. Glidden
- 1967: Donald R. Snyder
- 1968: Ernest B. Kelsay
- 1969: Calvin C. Barnham
- 1970: Philip G. Haigh
- 1971: Gordon L. Hummel
- 1972: Glenn I. Iverson
- 1973: Harold O. McDaniel, Jr.
- 1974: William E. Winner
- 1975: James E. McWhirter
- 1976: Jack L. Hurlburt
- 1977: Donald R. King
- 1978: Glen C. Youman
- 1979: Richard B. Eaton
- 1980: Alton E. Hutchinson
- 1981: Jack H. Kaiser
- 1982: Jack L. Hummel
- 1983:Hugh A. Shuffleton, Jr.
- 1984: Thomas H. Blankenship
- 1985: Floyd E. Prather
- 1986: Donald J. Cross
- 1987: Robart G. Sanderson
- 1988: Robart G. Sanderson
- 1989: Bryant R. Carter
- 1990: James D. Byers
- 1991: Hugh A. Shuffleton, III
- 1992: Thomas D. Chappelle, Jr.
- 1993: Ronald L. Craddock
- 1994: David E. Walker
- 1995: Douglas E. Will
- 1996: Robert W. Nidever
- 1997: Hugh A. Shuffleton, III
- 1998: Patrick R. Casady
- 1999: John R. Murray
- 2000: Emil Gene Kalbaugh
- 2001: Alton E. Hutchinson
- 2002: Hugh A. Shuffleton, III
- 2003: Bill W. Stewart
- 2004: Keith A. McIntosh
- 2005: Richard T. Montgomery
- 2006: Ronald L. Craddock
- 2007: Ronald L. Craddock